Multicultural, Total Market, Cross-cultural, What Does It All Mean? – HispanicAd.com

November 08, 2013 by Jose Villa.- There has been a pivot in the last five years to a new lexicon and strategy of integration in the world of Hispanic, and multicultural marketing. The rapid growth of Hispanic, Asian, African-American and other ethnic populations, and the trend towards ethnic “minority majorities” has moved multicultural marketing out of the silos and into the C-suites of many large companies. What was once a niche is now mainstream. This growth in ethnic markets has been accompanied by a shift in marketing strategies by major marketers towards efficiency and integration. The result has been an introduction of new marketing models changing the way organizations approach ethnic marketing.

November 08, 2013 by Jose Villa / SENSIS

There has been a pivot in the last five years to a new lexicon and strategy of integration in the world of Hispanic, and multicultural marketing. The rapid growth of Hispanic, Asian, African-American and other ethnic populations, and the trend towards ethnic “minority majorities” has moved multicultural marketing out of the silos and into the C-suites of many large companies. What was once a niche is now mainstream. This growth in ethnic markets has been accompanied by a shift in marketing strategies by major marketers towards efficiency and integration. The result has been an introduction of new marketing models changing the way organizations approach ethnic marketing.

Whenever there is a new trend in business – or society for that matter – there is initially confusion: new terms, divergent definitions, and overlapping concepts. This has been happening in the multicultural marketing industry, with three concepts dominating the discussion and fueling confusion: 1) multicultural marketing, 2) total market approach, and 3) cross-cultural marketing. This was in full view at the recently concluded ANA Multicultural Marketing Conference, where almost every panel and presentation invoked some variation or interpretation of these models. […]

The Association of Hispanic Advertising Agencies (AHAA) recently released the first results of its “Total Market Benchmark Study” to define the “total market approach.” […] However, even with these initial positions and a heightened discussion, there is still confusion. Here’s my perspective on what I see as three distinctive models to ethnic marketing.

Multicultural Marketing – targeted marketing efforts to specific, clearly defined ethnic groups. […]

Total Market Approach – one marketing program designed to reach all consumers, across general and ethnic markets.
The total market approach describes a controversial, yet increasingly popular new avenue used by many marketers, particularly large national advertisers. According to the AHAA total market study, industry executives define total market as reflecting diversity in all their marketing (including using diverse talent), leveraging cultural cues, and focusing on universal truths to gain efficiencies. While AHAA offers two models to Total Market, I feel that in practice, total market is about the “adaptation” model as a shift away from ethnic-specific targeting. […]

Cross-Cultural Marketing – one marketing program that leverages ethnic markets to reach across ethnic and general markets […] The difference between total market and cross-cultural is subtle, but important. It’s all about the role of ethnic consumers, which are front and center in a cross-cultural model. Cross-cultural marketing is most aligned with AHAA’s “integration” model and McDonald’s well-known mantra of “leading with ethnic insights.” Ethnic markets drive the general market, versus the other way around in both the total market and multicultural models. […]

So is there a right model? I don’t think so. I firmly believe all three models are relevant, in use and providing ROI in 2013. The big question is whether that will be the case in five to 10 years.

Read FULL ARTICLE in HispanicAd.com

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

ANA/AIMM Commitment to Systemic Change in Marketing

Join the pledge crop

At ANA and AIMM, we strongly believe that every person — regardless of race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, gender identity, ability, […]

CIIM Ads Insights – INFOGRAPHICS

Slider_ciim

CIIM makes a direct correlation between culture and business performance such as enhance brand perception, increased ad effectiveness, and lift […]

CIIM Programming Insights – INFOGRAPHIC

CIIM programming1-pic

Cultural Insight Impact Measure is the industry leading metric that validates the impact and effectiveness of cultural insights in ads […]

These 6 Ads Are the Most Effective Multicultural Marketing Messages in Recent Years

gillette-culturally-relevant

“Nothing Comes Easy” by Grey New York for Procter & Gamble is among a small group of top-performing multicultural ads. […]